Should Whole Grains, Seeds, or Nuts be Used in Sourdough Starter?

The age-old tradition of sourdough baking has its roots in capturing wild yeasts and bacteria from the environment to naturally ferment dough. At the heart of this process lies the sourdough starter, typically a blend of flour and water. While white refined flour has been the conventional choice, the modern health-conscious era sees bakers exploring alternative ingredients. Whole grains, seeds, and nuts have become exciting frontiers. Let’s dive into understanding the role and viability of these ingredients in a sourdough starter.

Incorporating whole grains into a sourdough starter can introduce diverse microbes and nutrients, enhancing fermentation. However, seeds or nuts may interfere with the starter’s microbial balance as their natural oils can upset the microbial balance. For consistent results, add whole grains, seeds or nuts directly to the dough rather than the starter, preserving the starter’s health and fermentation capabilities.

Considerations in using Whole Grains, Seeds and Nuts in Sourdough STarters

 1. Whole Grains

Whole grains, encompassing the bran, germ, and endosperm, are nutritionally superior to refined grains. Their integral nature means they’re rich in fibers, vitamins, and other essential nutrients.

By using whole grains, you’re injecting a greater quantity of essential nutrients into your bread. Whole grains like whole wheat or rye can lend a rustic, deep taste to sourdough. Whole grains, particularly rye, often lead to a lively starter. The bran offers additional nutrition, fueling the yeast and bacteria.

Considerations: Whole grain starters might appear denser due to their tendency to absorb more water. These starters might need more frequent nourishment to remain bubbly and active.

 2. Seeds

Seeds like flax, chia, and sesame aren’t traditional sourdough ingredients, but their nutritional merits make them intriguing additions.

Seeds can be a powerhouse of minerals, fibers, and beneficial fats. Depending on the seed, they can provide a unique mouthfeel and taste to the final bread.

Considerations: Seeds lack the carbohydrate profile that grains offer, making them secondary players in the fermentation game. They work best in tandem with grain flours. Chia and flaxseeds, for instance, are notorious for their water-absorbing qualities. When incorporating them, it is important to increase the hydration.

 3. Nuts

Though unconventional, nuts in powdered form present an opportunity to impart a distinct flavor profile and nutrient boost.

Nut flours, from almonds to cashews, can infuse the sourdough with a rich, nutty undertone. Nuts are rich in healthy fats, proteins, vitamins, and minerals.

Considerations: Like seeds, nuts aren’t primary fermentation agents. They should be paired with traditional or whole grain flours for optimal results. Premium nut flours can be quite pricey.

Best Practices for Incorporating Whole Grains, Seeds, and Nuts:

1. Start Small

If you’re venturing into this territory for the first time, begin by introducing these ingredients in small proportions. Monitor how your starter responds.

2. Watch the Water

As you incorporate seeds or nut flours, be mindful of the dough’s hydration. Some ingredients may necessitate more water.

3. Maintain a Backup

It’s always a good practice to keep a portion of your original starter aside, just in case a new experiment doesn’t pan out.

4. Temperature Matters

Whole grains, seeds, and nuts might change the optimal fermentation temperature for your starter. Keep an eye out for signs of over or under fermentation.

5. Freshness Factor

Ensure the seeds and nut flours are fresh. Rancid nuts can impact the flavor negatively.


The universe of sourdough is vast and full of possibilities. Whole grains undoubtedly present a beneficial and flavorful choice for starters. Seeds and nuts, while secondary in the fermentation hierarchy, can play a substantial role in enhancing flavor, texture, and nutrition.

Modern baking is all about innovation. While traditions lay the foundation, incorporating whole grains, seeds, and nuts can lead to delightful, nutritious twists in the sourdough tale. Embrace the experimentative spirit, but do so with knowledge and care, and the results can be incredibly rewarding.


Hey there! I'm Sam, your go-to pal for all things sourdough. I've been baking and kneading for 10 fun-filled years, and I can't wait to share the joy of turning simple ingredients into heavenly sourdough bread with you. Grab your apron and let's dive into this amazing world of sourdough bread together on this blog.

Recent Posts