Herbs and Spices in Sourdough Starters: A Good Idea?

Sourdough bread, with its distinctive tangy flavor, has long been a favorite among bakers. Traditional sourdough starter is a simple mixture of flour and water, allowing wild yeast and bacteria to flourish. But what if we add a twist to this ancient formula by incorporating spices or herbs? Let’s dive into the concept and explore the possibilities, advantages, challenges, and best practices of adding spices or herbs to a sourdough starter.

Adding spices or herbs directly to a sourdough starter isn’t recommended. They can interfere with the microbial balance and activity essential for fermentation. If you want a flavored sourdough bread, it’s better to add these ingredients during the bread-making process, ensuring the starter’s health and activity remain uncompromised.

Pros and Cons of Incorporating Spices and Herbs

Bakers have always experimented, looking for ways to tweak flavors and create unique baked goods. Spices and herbs, with their vast range of flavors, aromas, and cultural associations, present an intriguing avenue for experimentation. From the warming notes of cinnamon and nutmeg to the aromatic allure of rosemary and thyme, these ingredients can dramatically alter the sensory experience of bread.

1. Spices

Pros: Introducing spices can add warmth, sweetness, or a hint of exoticism to your bread. Ingredients like cinnamon or cardamom can evoke particular cultural or festive associations.

Cons: Spices can be potent. An overpowering spice might drown out the bread’s natural flavors. Additionally, some spices, due to their natural antimicrobial properties, might inhibit the growth of yeast or bacteria.

2. Herbs

Pros: Fresh or dried herbs can introduce refreshing and savory elements. Think of the earthy richness of rosemary or the summery lightness of basil.

Cons: Like spices, herbs can have antimicrobial properties. There’s also the risk of introducing contaminants from fresh herbs, potentially upsetting the starter’s microbial balance.

Considerations and Challenges

1. Microbial Dynamics

The fundamental concern is the potential impact of spices and herbs on the microbial balance. Any antibacterial or antifungal properties could inhibit the growth of essential microbes.

2. Flavor Balance

While introducing new flavors is the goal, one needs to be careful to ensure the end product isn’t overwhelming. The nuanced tang of sourdough should complement, not compete with, the added ingredients.

3. Consistency and Texture

Some spices and herbs might change the starter’s consistency, potentially affecting the bread’s texture.

4. Allergic Reactions

Uncommon spices or herbs might trigger allergies or sensitivities in some individuals. It’s essential to be aware of this, especially when sharing or selling the bread.

Guidelines for Experimentation

1. Begin with a Separate Batch

Before making wholesale changes to your primary starter, set aside a smaller portion for experimentation. This way, any adverse effects won’t jeopardize your main batch.

2. Introduce Gradually

Instead of adding a large quantity at once, gradually introduce the herb or spice, observing any changes in the starter’s behavior and aroma.

3. Regularly Monitor

Keep an eye on your experimental batch. Signs of mold, unusual odors, or reduced activity can be indications that the introduced ingredient is negatively impacting the starter.

4. Incorporate During Baking

If you’re wary of affecting your starter’s balance but still want the flavor, consider adding the spices or herbs directly to the dough during the baking process.

5. Engage with the Community

The world of sourdough baking has a vast and passionate community. Share your experiments, seek advice, and learn from the experiences of others.


The journey of sourdough baking is one of patience, observation, and continual learning. Introducing spices and herbs to this equation adds another layer of complexity but also opens up a world of flavor possibilities. While the road is fraught with potential pitfalls, the rewards – a loaf infused with the aromatic depth of spices or the refreshing notes of herbs – can be incredibly satisfying. The key lies in balancing respect for tradition with the joy of experimentation, ensuring that the ancient art of sourdough baking continues to evolve and surprise.


Hey there! I'm Sam, your go-to pal for all things sourdough. I've been baking and kneading for 10 fun-filled years, and I can't wait to share the joy of turning simple ingredients into heavenly sourdough bread with you. Grab your apron and let's dive into this amazing world of sourdough bread together on this blog.

Recent Posts